Don't worry, you won't have to drool over my mad photoshop skills anymore. I have the fabric, in the flesh, and you can see for yourself how great this dress will look:
I got a little fancy with my fabric this time. I wish I had gotten the same style in fabric for both, but they are close enough. The hot momma red skirt is a stretch poplin and the sleeves a stretch sateen. I wish both had been sateen, but that wasn't an option for this last minute shopper. Fortunately, they are similarly shiny, so it doesn't look weird. I did have a pencil skirt made in gray poplin that I LOVED, so maybe I can recreate that magic here.
The stretch is not too strong, they are both sturdy fabrics, so I'm happy to revisit my old nemesis on somewhat kinder terms.